Tag: collective custom build

  • HPH077 : Inspiration as a Big Developer Loses Out on a Plot to a Local Group – with Jackson Moulding from Ashley Vale

    HPH077 : Inspiration as a Big Developer Loses Out on a Plot to a Local Group – with Jackson Moulding from Ashley Vale

    Jackson Moulding from Ecomotive tells the story of Ashley Vale, a group self build scheme in Bristol, UK, that initially had to fend off a large developer in order to secure a plot of land. The will of the local community was instrumental in making this happen.

    Jackson-Moulding

     

    Interview with Jackson Moulding

    Jackson Moulding didn’t intend to build a house but he craved living more sustainably. As he couldn’t afford to buy a house he turned to self build as an option to realise his dreams.

    Ashley Vale houses

    A Planning Application on a Nearby Site by a Developer Spurred the Local Community to Explore Alternatives

    A local community group formed in response to the developer’s planning application. The group did not want to see the usual generic housing model so set about looking at what else could be done with the site.

    A member of the group lived on the edge of the site in their own self build house, and this helped inspire the members to pursue the idea of empowering people to build their own homes.

     

    Negotiations Were Already Underway Between the Land Owner and the Developer

    The site was owned by a scaffolding company who had no particular interest in selling to the community. With the developer’s planning application already in place the community group knew they couldn’t just object to the plans but they would need to put forward some alternatives. Firstly they put forward their case of why the plans didn’t reflect what the community wanted, whilst also working out their own plans for a more mixed use, sustainable scheme.

     

    Using Inspiration from Other Schemes the Group Were Motivated to Pursue Self Build

    Members of the newly formed group researched existing group self build schemes, such as Findhorn in Scotland and Christiania in Copenhagen and took inspiration from this. Along with the encouragement of some of the people who had been at their original community meeting, and particularly from those who had already self built, they were confident that a sustainable self build scheme would meet the objectives of the area.

     

    The Design Process Was Undertaken While Simultaneously Fighting the Planning Application

    A number of conditions of the site had to be dealt with first, such as underground waterways and sewage pipes, before the layout and size of plots was determined. The cost price of the individual plots was based on the division of the land price together with an estimation of other things such as the costs of putting the services in.

     

    Interested Individuals Were Asked to Provide a Deposit Before Their Own Plans Had Gained Planning Approval

    People who had expressed interest at one of the local events in purchasing a plot were asked to put down their 10% deposit once they had been successful in getting the developer’s planning application rejected. This sum amounted to £3000. At the point of exchange with the land owner they were all asked to produce the rest of the money for their plots, which became a fairly complicated process requiring legal representation from the action group, the land owner, and the self-builders.

     

    The Community Group Were Not the Self-Builders

    While only a few of the Ashley Vale Action Group (or their family members), including Jackson, did become one of the self-builders, the majority were involved just as interested community members who wanted to create the opportunity for other people to be able to live in the area in an affordable and sustainable way.

    Ashley-Vale-4

     

    The Project Benefitted From Being a Group of Individual Self-Builders Rather Than a Cohousing Scheme

    With the plots being sold as freehold, the owners were able to have complete freedom in how they wished to design and build their house, albeit within the action group’s policy of asking them to build sustainably, to think about their energy consumption, the materials they used and where they came from, and in a way that would be beneficial for future residents.

    Whereas cohousing schemes have the conditions that members work together to build each other’s houses with the associated potential dilemmas of working out how to attribute each person’s time, this group benefitted from having the flexibility to work to their own schedules.

    The community group established training sessions for the self-builders to learn about different aspects of sustainable building and established a co-operative so that members could benefit from the economies of scale of buying together.

    Some of the self-builders joined together to instruct timber frame manufacturers, whilst others did almost all of the hands-on building themselves.

    Ashley-Vale-3

     

    “The Journey is Crucial, Because it’s The Journey That Creates The Community”

    Although the process of allowing people to work to their own timescales meant that it was a building site for a number of years, Jackson credits it with fostering a sense of community. A number of the self-builders were living on site and with people at different stages of their builds there would always be someone to help out with advice about what they had done or were about to do.

     

    One House Remains Unfinished, 15 Years On

    Rather than being dictatorial, the community have tried to remain positive and provide encouragement and support to try and resolve this, even offering to buy the plot from the owner.

    At the outset one of their key criteria was this should be an opportunity for people who didn’t have a home. However Jackson acknowledges this was also balanced with who was also able to provide the money for the plots at the time the money was required.

    In this particular case the self-builder has other property which means it’s a shame that people are not using it as a home or living as part of the community.

     

    The Scheme has Received Worldwide Interest

    Delegations have visited from around the world, along with local school children and architecture students.

    As an off-shoot of the original community group they have set up an organisation called Ecomotive, which runs workshops to help people through the process of coming together as a group.

    This scheme undoubtedly is the result of a progressive and enthusiastic community which has utilised much local expertise to enable people who otherwise wouldn’t have been able to buy or build their own home.

    Ashley-Vale-5

     

    Find Out More

    Visit Ecomotive’s website

    Follow Ecomotive on Twitter

    Follow Jackson Moulding on Twitter

     

    Transcript

    Download a transcript of the interview with Jackson Moulding.

     

    Totnes Passivhaus Bed and Breakfast

    My wife and I recently visited Totnes on a research trip to experience a Passivhaus first hand. We can thoroughly recommend it. Not only can you ask hosts Adam and Erica all your Passivhaus questions, but you’ll be very well looked after and there’ll be a hearty British breakfast in the morning! You would also be in a beautiful part of the UK.

    If you want to find out more about the project, check out this video. It won in the UK Passivhaus Awards 2013.

     

    Please Connect With Me

  • HPH049 : Collective Custom Build – with David Rudlin from Urbed

    HPH049 : Collective Custom Build – with David Rudlin from Urbed

    David Rudlin from Urbed explains what collective custom build is and why it would be beneficial to build more houses this way.

     

    David Rudlin

     

    Interview with David Rudlin

    David Rudlin has been an urban planner for the last 25 years. Starting work on his own housing cooperative in the mid 1980s was a pivotal project and ever since he’s been driven by how communities can be empowered to get involved in their own housing and neighbourhoods.

     

    What is Collective Custom Build?

    To understand collective custom build let’s first define a couple of other terms. Self build is when you buy a plot, engage an architect (or create a design it yourself) and then you build it yourself with your own materials.

    Custom build is the process by which people can choose their own home before it’s built. So you find a plot, choose a manufacturer to create your house, buy one of those houses and they build it for you on the plot.

    Collective custom build, is a hybrid of the two, where a group of people come together and they buy a plot of land. They either get houses manufactured or more often they engage an architect and they create a design collectively for the site which they then jointly fund, jointly build, and it’s created for them.

    Collective custom build is most commonly a group of flats or apartments rather than individual houses.

    custom-build-ideas

     

    Working as a Group Helps Build the Community

    David talks through how he started the Yellow Bricks housing cooperative and acquired an acre of land in the middle of Hulme, Manchester, for the plot. It was a lengthy process, which started in 1986 and was completed in 1996.

    One of the benefits of doing custom build as a group is that you make very good friends so by the time you move in it’s almost an instant community.

     

    Custom Build Gives You Choice in the Design of Your House

    Normally you have to be quite rich to be able to design your own house, but going down this route allows you to create something that suits your needs.

     

    Land Varies Hugely in Value

    Land can be very expensive. David gives an example of how it’s twice as expensive in the UK as it would be in Holland to buy the same piece of land.

    There’s also a big difference between land that is for agricultural purposes, which may cost a few thousand pounds per acre, and land that has consent to build houses which may go up to £1 million an acre. Therefore you can generate value by getting consent for houses and instead of running off with the profits you can channel it into creating a better neighbourhood.

    Spare-plot-Almere

     

    Decide How You Want to Live

    There needs to be some agreement on issues such as where you want your kids to play, how you want them to grow up and relate to other people, etc.

    In the Yellow Bricks housing cooperative a lot of focus went into the middle garden courtyard.

    David says: “It now opened almost 20 years ago so there are kids who are now young adults who spent their childhood playing in this courtyard and you talk to these people and they say their childhood was different because of it.”

    Cohousing is another route to explore if you’re looking for a strong community.

     

    Shared Ownership Often Suits Group Custom Build

    Often with these projects you own a share in the company that owns the building. So you would have the equivalent value of your apartment but it would be tied to the overall value of the building.

     

    Finding the Right Developer Could Accelerate the Process

    David’s experience of collective custom build took 10 years because they did everything themselves. Although it was enjoyable it was also exhausting and David suggests that finding a developer that is keen to promote custom build could cut out a lot of the complication. This is because the developer will already have sites allocated for this and be looking for groups of people to come together to take things forward.

    Igloo is an example of a company that is doing this in the UK.

    Variety-in-Almere

     

    Almere is a Good Example of How Custom Build Can Work

    David talks about a significant development in Holland (which we have also mentioned in episode 6 and episode 37).

    The process of building a house is made much easier. You visit the plot shop to choose a site from a big map on the wall.

    Then there is a book full of house types and a list of 10 or so manufacturers who can produce these houses. You then customise the build to your needs (saying: “I’d like three bedrooms, very high energy efficiency, I’d like it to have a green roof . . .”) and sign a deal.

    The group custom build process is very similar. David continues: “What tends to happen is most group custom build people end up not being able to make the model fit their needs. So they end up either customising it so much that you’d hardly recognise it from the original version or they’d get in an architect to design it from scratch.”

    Bike-in-Almere

     

    The Biggest Challenge of Collective Custom Build is the Finances

    Getting a mortgage together is always a challenge even if you’re just buying a house yourself.

    So when you are talking about a group of people there is increased complication. Getting the deposits together can be hard work but then there is also the chance that one of the members might lose a job and not have the necessary funds.

    Having a plan for these scenarios upfront will make it easier to deal with these situations when they arise.

     

    Custom Build Should Mean More Variety

    Whereas custom build can account for over 50% of the market in countries like Switzerland, in the UK only 10% of houses are not built by developers.

    Also the 90% of UK housing that is built by developers is also a product of just 10 major house-builders and they offer little in the way of innovation.

    So custom build is likely to lead to a better quality of housing that is also more diverse.

     

    Energy Efficiency is Still a Trade-Off

    When asked whether custom build will lead to more sustainable housing, David replies that this is still unknown! It depends on people initiating the process. They can create an energy-efficient house or they can put that money into a kitchen or towards living in a slightly better area. So they are very real trade-offs.

    David says: “We’re hoping to get some research to work with Sheffield University to follow this through, to find out what people do actually choose, to see whether they choose the green option or whether they go for the larger space standard and so on, and to talk to the custom builders who sign up for that and understand what their motivations are and what drives them.”

     

    Resources on Collective Custom Build

    National Self Build Association

    Collective Custom Build

     

    Transcript

    Download a transcript of the interview with David Rudlin.

     

    Find Out More

    Urbed

     

     

     

    Follow Urbed on Twitter

     

    Crowdfunding a Documentary on Airtightness

    Hurrah! Our Kickstarter campaign has been approved and that means we will now launch on 1st May.

    We really hope you will be able to support us. Find out more information about the project.

     

    Please Connect With Me