Category: Building in the UK

  • From Passivhaus . . . to conventional house?

    From Passivhaus . . . to conventional house?

    What makes someone swap the comfort of a Passivhaus self-build for a conventional 1960s bungalow? Former ITV news cameraman Mike Coe explains his unexpected transition.

    When Mike Coe built his ultra-low-energy eco-build – the Cropthorne Autonomous House in Worcestershire – after he retired in 2006, he was determined to make a difference.

    Water neutral and off-grid apart from electricity, the house trod as lightly on the earth’s surface as possible. It encapsulated Mike’s optimism that UK housebuilding was on the cusp of change.

    But five years on, after much soul-searching, Mike and his partner Lizzie made the difficult decision to move on.

    A shift in values, combined with an appetite for new adventure, has taken the couple from the comfort of a Passivhaus with no heating system, which never fell below 16°C even on the chilliest of winter nights – to a three-bed 1960s bungalow in Portree on the Isle of Skye. So what changed?

    The comfortable Passivhaus they left behind

    Reality check

    “When we built The Autonomous House, I naively thought I was on the vanguard of some kind of movement in ultra-low energy homes,” says Mike. “But while I was attempting to build as ecologically as I possibly could, the government was in the process of trashing UK planning laws and allowing developers to build rubbish wherever they wanted. I became disillusioned quite quickly.

    “I still feel The Autonomous House itself has value and was a great project – but I lost my sense of optimism that it was the dawn of a new era.”

    Their current home – a traditionally built 1960s bungalow – is merely a temporary stop-over as they embark on another self-build challenge. And while Mike’s focus has changed since building his radical, largely off-grid Passivhaus, he hasn’t lost faith in low-energy building methods.

    “I still try to live in an environmentally sympathetic way – and my next house will be a Passivhaus,” says Mike. “But I no longer think anything I’m doing will have any great impact on the world.

    “Since retiring I returned to work as a cameraman, but only on carefully selected, mostly environmental projects. As a result I’ve met some of the world’s leading climate scientists and been able to talk to them informally. From what I’ve learned I’ve concluded that it could become uncomfortably hot in the south of England, even in my lifetime (I’m 60 now). This realisation was the trigger for a decision to move as far north as was practical without leaving the country – and we’ve ended up in Portree.”

    Portree

    Skye’s the limit

    In planning their move north, Mike’s original intention wasn’t to build again. Despite being very practical and capable – having done all the electrics, plumbing and more at Cropthorne – he doesn’t particularly enjoy the building process. The couple’s first thought was to find an existing house that they could adapt.

    “It quickly became obvious that we wouldn’t find anything that came close to what we had at Cropthorne in the areas we wanted to move to,” says Mike. “Once you’ve lived in a Passivhaus it’s very hard to settle for a conventional draughty house that’s expensive to heat and live in. So we decided to look for a temporary house, while we considered our options.”

    It was during this search that they heard about a building plot with planning – that also had ready-made accommodation on site.

    “While it wasn’t our intention to build again, the site we found, almost accidentally, had so much potential,” says Mike. “It had nine acres of croft land, two building plots with Permission in Principle (the Scottish equivalent of Outline Planning Permission) and a perfectly acceptable bungalow on site that we could move straight into. It was too good an opportunity to miss.

    “It’s rare to find somewhere with ready-made accommodation on site when you build. We can build a south-facing, solar-heated home here with views over Portree harbour and distant views of the Cuillins. It’s perfect.”

    View from the Croft

    ‘Conventional’ house v Passivhaus

    So how does living back in a ‘normal’ home compare to the comfort of living in the Cropthorne Passivhaus?

    “The most notable thing is how rapidly the temperature inside conventional buildings follows the temperature outside,” says Mike. “The heating goes off and half an hour later you notice that it’s really cooling down. Two hours later, it’s freezing.

    “In our Passivhaus, which was high-mass with thermal storage in the structure of the building, the process was slowed down. In autumn, when you started getting chilly nights, you simply weren’t aware of it.

    “Living here has made me realise how lucky we’ve been to live in a Passivhaus. The bungalow’s clunky old oil boiler drinks kerosene that I have to pay for. It’s not cheap – whereas at Cropthorne we had no heating bills, and it was more comfortable. That’s a stark contrast.”

    The warm and cosy upstairs at the Cropthorne Autonomous House

    Laying plans for a new adventure

    What of Mike’s plans for the new build? Have his shifting views led to a fundamentally different approach this time?

    “It will still be a very low energy design for both comfort and running costs, because it’s a good way to live,” says Mike. “It just won’t have unrealistic goals.

    “With the Cropthorne project we were quite hard line. The house used entirely harvested rainwater, we had composting toilets, and everything was designed to minimise impact. We’ll still follow that path to some extent. For example, we’ll aim for zero heat, even though the climate here is different. There’s also a stream running down the site that should be capable of powering a small hydro generator to provide some of our electricity. Eventually we may even add a wind turbine.

    “But this house will have more mainstream appeal. The autonomous systems at Cropthorne were brilliant but they added to the costs, and you don’t get those back when you sell. We had practical reasons for doing what we did there. On Skye, water is in abundant supply, so we’ll probably connect to the mains.

    “So, overall, the new house will still be very comfortable, environmentally benign and energy-efficient, but will be more mainstream and more saleable – just in case I have another brilliant idea in five years’ time and we end up moving again!”

    Artist’s impression of Portree Passivhaus
  • Financing an Ecological Build – with Jon Lee from Ecology Building Society

    Have you taken a serious look at the finances of your build?

    Are you being realistic with how much money you have and how much you will be able to borrow?

    In this article, I’m going to get an introduction to financing a low energy build with some help from Jon Lee, Business Development Manager at Ecology Building Society.

    Ecology-Building-Society-Logo-web

    I must admit that the House Planning Help blog has almost entirely been consumed by design issues and working out what could be built. None of that has got realistic and considered cost but I’m hoping to change that now. Nobody wants to be the person who runs out of money and options, so where is that sweet spot of getting the finances just right?

    ebs-wall-1

    Talk to a Number of Potential Finance Providers

    This advice would make sense for any service one would hope to procure but it’s relevant here because there are various types of self build mortgage and it does depend on your own financial situation as to which route will be best to go down. Jon Lee says: “Some lenders will provide funds only at a time when you’ve already bought the plot and you’re actually improving the value of the site by physically building. Other lenders will be more comfortable helping towards the financial purchase of the land as long as it’s got planning consent.”

     

    Payments Made Against Increasing Value of the Plot

    As with any financing the lender will need security. In this case it is a plot of land, which will change in value at various stages throughout the build. “In those interim phases where actually you’re doing quite a lot of work on a self build, it doesn’t necessarily correlate with spend against improved value. There’s quite a curve there and as you get towards the end of the build you tend to add a lot of value for not much more spend.”

    After kitchens and bathrooms (and so on) have gone in, it becomes a much more marketable asset.

    ebs-doors-1

    Generally Stage Payments are Drawn Down in Arrears

    Once you have an approved mortgage, there will be certain milestones where the interim value of the site is calculated. At these points your lender will work out how much of your retention can be drawn against that and a tranche payment is made in arrears of the work. However, some lenders offer an ‘accelerator’ mortgage which would provide funds in advance, so effectively giving you the money to do the next phase of works and then having the revaluation done. As this is more risky for the lender, ultimately it costs more.

     

    Ideally You Would Have Equity to Borrow Against

    Jon outlines a simple situation that shows why you would want to have a good sum of your own money invested in the project. Consider a plot that’s going to cost £100,000. If you needed to borrow £80,000 of that, the lender might look at your income and the scheme and think it looks interesting. Even though your plans for the plot may suggest that the finished project will be worth £250,000 if you’re borrowing £80,000 on day one you would have to consider where the funds are coming from for the rest of the build. At the Ecology Building Society the maximum loan to value is 90% on the residential mortgage, which would mean there’s only really another £10,000 available to help you proceed with the building work (unless you’ve got other capital or help from the bank of Mum and Dad, etc.).

    In this scenario an accelerator mortgage would be most appropriate, but it would be more expensive in terms of interest fees and arrangement fees. Plus if the budget got out of hand or a contractor let you down, you may be sailing very close to the wind!

    Architectural project

    Ecology Building Society Like to Work with Valuers Who Understand Low Energy Builds

    Jon stresses that it’s an important part of the process that both the valuer and the lender understand the type of construction, the materials being used and what the expected costings might be. Jon says: “We’d always ask the valuer to pass comment on whether they think the costings are realistic for what’s being proposed as well as taking on board the expertise or otherwise of the borrower themselves. They may well be serial self-builders. They could be people who have a background in building or architecture and so on and so forth. All of these things get taken into account.”

     

    Don’t Over-Stretch Yourself

    You may have read case studies of where multiple difficulties have led to the self or custom builder being unable to borrow any more. A good lender will be accessing the risk in the early stages. Jon explains: “Certainly the net book value of what is being mortgaged is inevitably a primary consideration as well as making sure that the borrower is not being over-stretched in terms of their ability to cover interest payments during the build phase, especially if they’re having to take a sabbatical from their day-job to see the project through.”

     

    Don’t be Put Off if You Haven’t Been Through the Process Before

    While it’s always preferable to have as much detail as possible about the cost of a build and quotes to back it up, Jon admits that some of the best schemes he’s seen have been from people who openly admit they haven’t got a formal business plan and are working their way through.

    ebs-during-build-1

    Not Being a Volume Lender Allows for a Much More Personal Service

    Ecology Building Society underwrites about 20 to 25 mortgages a month. As they are not a volume lender they are more able to cope with projects on an individual basis. This is particularly relevant when that don’t necessarily fit the normal system.

     

    Best Discounts For High Energy Efficiency

    Clearly as the Ecology Building Society aims to support a more sustainable future, it offers its best discounts for projects that either benefit the environment or the community. Buildings that meet the Passivhaus standard are rewarded with the top of the range discount off their standard variable rate. Find out more about their C-Change discounts, which run from Passivhaus down to Code for Sustainable Homes Level 4 or properties that achieve at least a B-rating on an Energy Performance Certificate (EPC).

     

    Underwriters Want to See Investment in the Building’s Envelope

    As ecological construction is fundamental to their business, it falls to the underwriters to make decisions on granting these discounted mortgages. Jon continues: “Our staff are well trained to be able to look at, not only the projected EPC which any property needs to have [in the UK] but also to look in more detail at the materials that have been used. For example, we don’t lend on new builds even if they do achieve the required level if the borrower is putting in UPVC windows and doors. We’d be looking for other clues that sustainable materials were at the heart of the build so things like a good standard of glazing, decent levels of insulation, natural materials and where possible locally-sourced materials.”

    They will also not rule out other options – such as a kit home that’s been sourced and shipped from Sweden – so as long as it’s still using sustainable materials.

     

    Talk to Your Finance Provider Early on

    As with most members of the construction team, it makes sense for your finance provide to be involved from the initial stages. In other words, don’t wait until you’ve bought the plot before you begin to look for finance. Lenders like to take everything into account at the early stages. Jon highlights why this is a good idea: “We can maybe advise them as to how much deposit they should be considering putting forward at the land purchase stage, how much they need to hold back for some of the works and work out the project with them in partnership so that you’ve got a really clear timeline and stress-tested cash flow. We can then see what happens if there’s a bit of a move in interest rates, if there’s a bit of a move in property prices, if heaven forbid costs start to rise, so that we can see what the sort of risk appraisal is and advise on the project in a very hands-on way to try and mitigate against nasty surprises.”

     

    Expect Some Challenges During the Build

    All projects will have aspects that change. Jon cannot remember any project that has gone exactly as planned where the budget has been spot on. Of course sometimes that can be in your favour and savings can be made on what you thought you were going to borrow. Assuming that a 10% contingency will get you out of all problems could be a mistake.

     

    Stress-Testing is to Help Not Hinder

    Applying a stress-test on a project and considering different eventualities makes sure that both the borrower and the lender have got a good understanding of what’s going to happen. It brings clarity over who’s going to be doing what and how things will be certified.

     

    Develop a Personal Relationship with Your Borrower

    Jon’s final bit of advice is to get to know your lender and to have a personal relationship where ever possible. Going through a broker will put you at arms length from whoever is providing the finance. As well as adding an extra layer of cost, you don’t get that rapport to be able to tackle problems that may crop up during the build.

     

    Ecology-Building-Society-Logo-web

     

     

     

    Visit the Ecology Building Society for more information and case studies.

    Follow Ecology Building Society on Twitter

     

    How are you going to finance your build? Have you got a healthy contingency planned?

  • How to Find a Good Value Plot of Land?

    How to Find a Good Value Plot of Land?

    Finding land

    There is no doubt about it, getting land is difficult. You need determination and the skills of a detective to pull it off.

    It’s pretty easy to subscribe to one of the websites that list all the plots of land that are available. Unfortunately, in the UK, there are over 100,000 people who also pay for this service and not that many suitable plots. Therefore it’s a race and whoever pays the most gets the prize.

    If the land has been advertised in any respect, even in a local newspaper or in the window of an estate agent, the chances are you will not be able to negotiate a good price. This is where the onus is on you to put in the research. It may involve a lot of groundwork but it is far more likely you’ll find a better plot at a better price.

    Firstly work out where you want to live. Broadly speaking the further you go from cities, the cheaper the land is and the more attractive it might be, too. For example, you can buy a plot of land in Northern Ireland for around £20,000 whereas you might spend upwards of £200,000 to find a decent plot within the M25. Also bear in mind that building materials, rates and labour may be cheaper in certain areas than others.

    Once you have narrowed down your search to a few villages, a town or a few square miles, order a gigantic scale Ordnance Survey map which has got every single detail on it, right down to the fences and manhole covers. This will allow you to highlight areas that are worth investigating on foot. If you spot a row of houses that have very large gardens, walk past them to ascertain whether there might be any opportunities. If there’s a garden that looks neglected or overgrown, perhaps the owner would be willing to sell off a section because it’s clearly too much to manage and maintain.

    There’s no substitute for walking around, looking over fences and knocking on doors. They may politely say no, but occasionally they will like the idea. If it’s an elderly couple with a big garden that they can’t look after, then somebody knocking at the door and offering £100,000 for a portion might be the perfect solution. Do make sure that you understand the planning situation, as well, so that you get to grips with what is realistic and what isn’t.

    Using social media could be another interesting route to try. Put up a message on Facebook saying you’re looking for a site in a certain area. Does anyone have parents, uncles, aunts or other relatives who might have a bit of land to sell?!